The quitclaim deed vs warranty deed question comes down to one word: promises. A warranty deed makes them, and a quitclaim deed does not. Both can move a Florida property from one person to another, and both get recorded the same way. However, the buyer on the other end gets very different protection. This guide explains what each deed actually warrants, why title insurers handle quitclaims with care, when families use them, and the tax and recording rules that apply no matter which form you pick.
Quitclaim Deed vs Warranty Deed: The Short Answer
A warranty deed is the seller's guarantee. The seller says they own the property, that they have the right to sell it, and that they will defend the buyer's title against other claims. If one of those promises turns out to be false, the buyer can sue the seller.
A quitclaim deed is a release. The grantor hands over whatever interest they have, if any, and walks away. They do not say they own anything. If it later turns out that someone else owned the house, the buyer has no claim against the person who signed.
So the quitclaim deed vs warranty deed choice is really a choice about risk. With a warranty deed, the seller keeps some of it. With a quitclaim, the buyer takes all of it.
What Does a General Warranty Deed Promise?
Florida's statutory form of warranty deed sits in section 689.02. Under section 689.03, a deed made substantially in that form is a warranty deed with full common-law covenants. Those covenants bind the grantor and the grantor's heirs, as if each promise were written out in full.
In plain terms, the common-law covenants cover four ideas. First, the seller owns the property. Second, the seller has the right to convey it. Third, there are no liens or other claims except the ones listed in the deed. Finally, the seller will defend the buyer's title against anyone with a lawful claim.
Those promises reach back through the whole history of the property, not just the seller's own years. That is why lawyers call it a general warranty. Most residential sales in Florida close with one. For example, the standard Florida purchase contract calls for a statutory warranty deed, unless the seller is a trustee, personal representative or guardian signing in that role.
What Does a Special Warranty Deed Promise?
A special warranty deed makes the same kinds of promises, but only for a limited time. The seller warrants against claims by, through or under the seller. In other words, the seller promises that nothing they did, or let happen, clouds the title. They make no promise about anything that happened before they owned it.
Builders, banks selling foreclosed homes and companies selling commercial property often use this form. They may have owned the land briefly, so they will not vouch for decades of history they never saw. Then the buyer relies on title insurance for the older risks.
For most buyers, the difference between general and special warranty matters less than it sounds. The buyer's owner's policy covers covered defects from any period, no matter which deed the seller signs. Our guide to what title insurance is explains how that coverage works.
What Does a Quitclaim Deed Do?
A quitclaim deed passes whatever interest the grantor holds at that moment. If the grantor owns the whole property, the buyer gets the whole property. If the grantor owns a half share, the buyer gets a half share. And if the grantor owns nothing, the buyer gets nothing, with no warranty to fall back on.
That makes a quitclaim a useful tool for cleanup. It lets someone who might have an interest release it without vouching for the title. For instance, an ex-spouse can release any claim after a divorce, or a relative can release a possible inheritance. In both cases, the person signing does not want to promise anything about the title. They only want to step aside.
Here is a side-by-side look at the quitclaim deed vs warranty deed choice, with the special warranty deed in the middle.
| Feature | General warranty deed | Special warranty deed | Quitclaim deed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Says the grantor owns the property | Yes | Yes, for the grantor's period | No |
| Covers title defects before the grantor | Yes | No | No |
| Grantor must defend the title | Yes | Only for the grantor's period | No |
| Typical use | Ordinary home sales | Builders, banks, commercial | Family transfers, releases, cleanup |
Why Title Insurers Treat Quitclaims With Caution
A title insurer reads every deed in the chain of title. When it finds a quitclaim, it asks a simple question: why did the grantor refuse to make any promises? Often the answer is harmless. Still, the examiner has to check.
There are several reasons for that caution. First, a quitclaim carries no warranty, so if a problem surfaces later, the insurer cannot recover its loss from the grantor. Next, quitclaims are often signed without a closing, without a title search and without a lawyer. As a result, they are more likely to contain errors in the legal description or the names. They also show up in disputes over divorce, death and debt, which are the same places where title fights start.
In practice, a quitclaim in the chain rarely stops a sale. The examiner may ask for an affidavit explaining it, a corrective deed, or proof that the grantor actually held title. Sometimes the fix is a new deed from the original owner. Rarely, when an old quitclaim leaves a real gap, the cure is a quiet title action.
Can You Buy a House With a Quitclaim Deed?

You can, but you should not accept one in a normal purchase. A buyer paying full price should insist on a warranty deed and an owner's title policy. The quitclaim deed vs warranty deed decision on a sale is almost always settled in favor of the warranty deed for that reason. If a seller will only sign a quitclaim, treat it as a warning sign and ask why.
When Do Families Use Quitclaim Deeds?
Families use quitclaims because they are quick and the people involved trust each other. Common examples include adding a spouse or child to the title, or removing an ex-spouse after a divorce. Another is moving a house into a revocable trust or a family LLC.
In those cases there is no buyer who needs protection. The person signing usually owns the property already, and the person receiving it knows the history. So the lack of warranties costs little. Still, a quitclaim does not remove a mortgage. The loan stays in place, and the original borrower stays liable on it.
Families also use other deed forms for estate planning. For example, a parent who wants a home to pass at death without probate may use an enhanced life estate deed instead. Our guide to the lady bird deed in Florida covers that option.
Homestead Property and Spousal Joinder
Homestead rules apply to every type of deed. Article X, section 4 of the Florida Constitution says a married owner may sell, give away or mortgage homestead only if the spouse joins. That rule holds even when the spouse is not on title.
So a married owner cannot quitclaim the family home to a child, or to anyone else, without the spouse signing too. A deed that skips the spouse may be void as to the homestead. Title insurers check marital status on every deed for that reason. Our post on whether a spouse can sell without permission goes deeper into the joinder rule.
The same caution applies when the person who receives the property is married. If they move in and claim it as homestead, their spouse may later need to join in any future sale.
Documentary Stamp Tax on Transfers Between Relatives
Many families assume a deed to a relative is tax-free. Sometimes it is, but the type of deed has nothing to do with it. Florida's documentary stamp tax depends on the consideration, which is what the grantee pays or takes on in exchange.
Under section 201.02, the tax is 70 cents per $100 of consideration. Consideration includes money paid, and it also includes the amount of any mortgage on the property, whether or not the new owner assumes it. So if a parent deeds a house with a $200,000 mortgage to a child, the stamps are figured on $200,000, even if the child pays nothing.
Florida Department of Revenue rules treat a true gift of property with no mortgage as not taxable. However, a deed that recites a token amount, such as ten dollars or love and affection, generally owes the minimum tax of 70 cents. Section 201.02 also exempts a deed of homestead between spouses when the only consideration is the existing mortgage. It also exempts certain transfers of the marital home between spouses as part of a divorce.
These rules turn on the facts, so ask before you record. A mortgaged property deeded to a relative is the case that most often surprises people.
Recording the Deed
A deed works between the people who sign it as soon as it is delivered. Still, it protects the new owner against the rest of the world only once it is recorded with the clerk of court in the county where the property sits. That rule applies equally to a quitclaim and a warranty deed.
Florida also has formal requirements. Under section 689.01, the grantor signs in the presence of two subscribing witnesses. Then section 695.26 sets the recording rules. The clerk needs printed names under each signature, post-office addresses for the signers, the witnesses and each grantee, and the name and address of the person who prepared the deed. The first page also needs a blank three-inch square in the top right corner for the clerk.
Recording costs $10 for the first page and $8.50 for each extra page, plus any documentary stamps. Once recorded, the deed becomes part of the public chain. Our guide to what a Florida title looks like shows how that chain reads in the county records.
Bottom Line
The quitclaim deed vs warranty deed choice depends on who needs protection. A general warranty deed promises clean title from the start, a special warranty deed covers only the seller's own years, and a quitclaim promises nothing at all. For a purchase, insist on a warranty deed and an owner's policy. For a family transfer, a quitclaim can work, as long as you handle homestead joinder, doc stamps on any mortgage and proper recording.
Verified Title prepares and records deeds of every kind in all 67 Florida counties. If you are planning a transfer or reviewing a deed in your chain, contact our office and we will look at it with you.
